Reasoned Audacity

~Daily commentary on public policy and culture ~
Ranger Handbook

"Achieve maximum effect
by exhibiting
Reasoned Audacity."

Finalist Link

To Subscribe

Enter email address:

Must Read

Jack's blog!

Ipso Facto Comic

Speaking

Charmaine Speaking

Need a speaker? Click here to bring Charmaine to your event.

Recent events:

MOPS, Truro Church, Fairfax, Virginia

September 8th

Washington & Lee University, Washington D.C. Program, "Women and Politics"

May 13th.

Trinity Fellows, Charlottesville, VA, "Gay Marriage"

May 26th.

Cedarville College, April 14th.

Extra

Sex Trafficking PPT

Blue Star Banner

For Josh, Michael and Will.

Be safe.

MarchTogether

We Surf For You

« Not Impressed: Calculation is Not Character | Main | Big Man in Charge! »

Get Women Out of Combat

lori3.gif

Elaine Donnelly, President of the Center for Military Readiness and I were in a meeting recently at the Pentagon with the Secretary of the Army, Francis Harvey and four-star General Richard Cody, Army vice chief of staff to discuss women in combat. We discussed with them new Army policies that are putting female soldiers in combat zones.

Ironically, our travels then took us near Tuba City, Arizona, home of Lori Piestewa, Army Private First Class, the first female soldier killed in Iraq. The news was full of coverage of the services commemorating the second anniversary of the ambush in which Lori was captured and eventually killed on March 23, 2003.

Amidst all of the honor rightly due to Lori, no one is asking a critical question. Why? Why was Lori -- a woman and a mother -- close enough to combat to stumble directly into the vicious hands of the enemy?

I'll tell you why. And it's not just because she was a soldier.

We have a noble and honorable tradition of sparing women and children from combat. It's part of being a civilized culture. Some people cite female pilots from World War II as setting a precedent for putting women in combat. However, while those women did serve admirably in the war, they did not fly in combat zones and in combat missions.

President Bill Clinton's Secretary of Defense, the late Les Aspin, changed Defense Department policy in 1994 by removing "substantial risk of capture" from the regulations that defined a combat zone where women were not to be assigned.

Now, the Army is moving even further in the direction of assigning women to combat zones.

See this important article -- Elaine lays out details.

Watch this space for more. And comments are open below.

Salute to Mudville Gazette

And My View

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.charmaineyoest.com/cgi-bin/mt/mt-tb.cgi/2506

Comments

"Amidst all of the honor rightly due to Lori, no one is asking a critical question. Why? Why was Lori -- a woman and a mother -- close enough to combat to stumble directly into the vicious hands of the enemy?"

And amidst all this rhetoric I've yet to see a coherent arguement as to exectly why they should not be in combat. Provided that they are capable of doing the job.

Donnelly's arguements are primarly that women are possesed of such poor qualites in general that they are unfit for the military altogether. I realize that the it's the new "political correctness" to be anti-feminist, but that does seem to me to be taking things a bit too far. Besides being rather degrading to women, it simply doesn't make any sense. That makes it all the easier to dismiss.

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

Charmaine

About Charmaine

Writing

My writing over the years, and longer pieces: click here for more Reasoned Audacity.

Thatcher

"You turn if you want to. The lady's not for turning."
~ Margaret Thatcher, 1980

Blog Blurbs

The Penta-Posse

The Penta-Posse

The Occasional Adventures of the Penta-Posse: Diva, Dreamer, Dude, Dancer, and Darlin' Boo . . .


Prev | List | Random | Next
JoinPowered by RingSurf!

Israel

Comments

Email:

comments at charmaineyoest dot com
Messages sent to this email are assumed to be public and publishable.

Amazon Honor SystemClick Here to PayLearn More

Blogroll

The Cotillion

The Cotillion

Site Meter

Powered By

MovableType

Site maintained by

Disclaimer

This is Charmaine Yoest's personal website. The views expressed here are solely her own.

Copyright, All Rights Reserved

Charmaine Yoest, 2006